 |
| Nadja Benaissa |
The No Angels Nadja Benaissa singer was sentenced to two years probation, because they knowingly two men has been infected with HIV. The German AIDS Help, criticized the verdict, not merely because it failed in their opinion too mild, but too hard.
It is difficult to understand how it came to such a reaction from the AIDS Help. After all, this is an organization that is a public advocate of prevention. How can such an organization to protect imagine a person who knowingly infected others, so do the exact opposite of what the AIDS-Help is actually. Especially since it is Benaissa a prominent person is a role model, geared to the young people. What signal set the judiciary, the AIDS-Hilfe, and the media? Is the message "It's OK if you infect your partner, they have themselves to blame if they trust you?
The answer is obvious Yes! As long as there is a perpetrator and not a perpetrator. Benaissa would a man, would be public and the judiciary as well as the AIDS-Hilfe gone hard with her to court. This is demonstrated by cases in the past in which men for similar crimes like this just did not get lax with suspended sentences and were not sponsored by the AIDS assistance and the media.
The answer is obvious Yes! As long as there is a perpetrator and not a perpetrator. Benaissa would a man, would be public and the judiciary as well as the AIDS-Hilfe gone hard with her to court. This is demonstrated by cases in the past in which men for similar crimes like this just did not get lax with suspended sentences and were not sponsored by the AIDS assistance and the media.
punishment for men, women, the compassion
In the slightly older article "criminal law for men, psychiatry for women " published in the journal "Criminological Journal the author Maud Kips concludes that illegal behavior by women is not so little is in evidence than that of men because women are less delinquent. Instead, men and women are controlled in different ways and sanctioned. In men, then, rather the punitive and educational moment comes into play, while women are more likely delinquency is interpreted as a sign of neediness and vulnerability [1].
If many centuries later, a historian examine our age is, perhaps it will meet the prisons. It takes some buildings that are populated predominantly by male population. These buildings are well guarded, but not only the output is controlled, but almost more stringent of the input. Permission to enter the building is the result of a long, is interspersed with rituals procedure that extensive of a bureaucratic apparatus is kept in motion. You will note that this apparatus a selection between those who are allowed to enter this building and those who do not have access, makes, and that the most important criterion of selection the sex is.
[...] It is clear that it is psychiatry that - exercise social control over women, or rather, about their work - as a counterpart to the criminal law. The psychiatric science is concerned with the relationship of body and soul, and may seem therefore been particularly likely to confirm the one concept of women's roles, the women in their biological "fate" binds. Psychiatric patients may be seen as women, the limit of the " have exceeded typical female role. "
be also the opinion of the author of many crimes committed by women is not categorized as such.
Gerade die am häufigsten angewendeten Tatbestände des Strafrechts beziehen sich auf Bereiche, die fast ausschließlich von Männern besetzt sind oder ihrer “Ausstattung" entsprechen: die Wirtschaft - und darunter verstehe ich nicht die Wirtschaftskriminalität, sondern vor allem den Diebstahl und den Drogenhandel - sowie die Anwendung körperlicher Gewalt. Bereiche, die von Frauen besetzt sind, wie das Kindergebären, die Kindererziehung, die Pflege der Männer, die Haushaltung und das Unterhalten von (Familien-)-Beziehungen, finden sich im Strafrecht so gut wie nicht. Probleme, Konflikte und unerwünschtes Verhalten in diesen Bereichen werden nicht kriminalisiert, zum Teil sogar entkriminalisiert. Why women are not able to get a criminal status.
find the man behind it
The case Benaissa shows an example, that women experience is not necessarily so rare criminal or violent in appearance, because they are naturally the more peaceful race. Rather it is the company difficult to ascribe women the same degree of responsibility and guilt, as it is wont to do in men. Instead, find a shift of responsibility towards the male part of society, whenever a woman sits in the dock.
Where: find the man behind it . Does a woman ill, abused or murdered them about their own children, so, the focus on the partner or ex-partner, father or brother. He may have abused or neglected, they simply loved. He must be, who has driven this poor woman so far has not their mental abnormality or absence of their own empathy detected early enough. He must be to the helped her in time and she has left to the excessive demands.
The man behind must not be part of the present, must not stand up by connecting with what had happened. He is also the woman in the past all kinds of mental Wounds have caused or have simply violated only by their absence. Is there the man behind it not, the man has to serve about - the man as a collective, as the patriarchy that makes this woman's life hard and puts so their debt, at least. Men are such kindness, such a view of her biography and life circumstances are generally not given.
the victim is a man who then offers yet another variation, namely that the victims themselves to blame. Most recently, a message went through the press, after which a physician deliberately a male cyclist was almost totgefahren because it mirrors their geschrammt, und ihr den Mittefinger gezeigt hatte. Die Frau wurde zu einer langen Gefängnisstrafe verurteilt, die Seiten der Online-Medien aber füllten sich mit Kommentaren, nach denen das Opfer doch angeblich selber schuld sei, habe er die Frau doch "massivst provoziert". Das Urteil wurde von vielen als zu hart empfunden, man hatte Mitleid mit der Täterin, nicht aber mit dem Opfer.
Den Mann dahinter gibt es im Fall von Benaissa nicht, dafür aber den Mann darüber - den gibt es immer. Die Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe resümiert in ihrer Kritik über das Urteil, dass die Verhütung und Prävention einseitig Frauen zugeschrieben werde. Diese Behauptung ist nicht nur aus der Luft gegriffen, it is much harder in the face sentences of men in similar cases, pure nonsense. Rather, the argument of the alleged oppression of women is trying to deny female guilt. What must not, can not be flat.
is also the above-mentioned shifts the responsibility to observe the victim. "Self-blame" was sometimes the tenor in the media about the men in question, why did they not prevented? Well, perhaps because she trusted the woman - apparently a serious mistake, they will have learned their lesson. In addition, it was Benaissa, who knew of their infection, and not the men. Just the looks on die Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe, wenn sie anmahnt, dass mit einem solchen Urteil "die gemeinsame Verantwortung zweier Menschen außer Kraft" gesetzt werde.
the victim is a man who then offers yet another variation, namely that the victims themselves to blame. Most recently, a message went through the press, after which a physician deliberately a male cyclist was almost totgefahren because it mirrors their geschrammt, und ihr den Mittefinger gezeigt hatte. Die Frau wurde zu einer langen Gefängnisstrafe verurteilt, die Seiten der Online-Medien aber füllten sich mit Kommentaren, nach denen das Opfer doch angeblich selber schuld sei, habe er die Frau doch "massivst provoziert". Das Urteil wurde von vielen als zu hart empfunden, man hatte Mitleid mit der Täterin, nicht aber mit dem Opfer.
Den Mann dahinter gibt es im Fall von Benaissa nicht, dafür aber den Mann darüber - den gibt es immer. Die Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe resümiert in ihrer Kritik über das Urteil, dass die Verhütung und Prävention einseitig Frauen zugeschrieben werde. Diese Behauptung ist nicht nur aus der Luft gegriffen, it is much harder in the face sentences of men in similar cases, pure nonsense. Rather, the argument of the alleged oppression of women is trying to deny female guilt. What must not, can not be flat.
is also the above-mentioned shifts the responsibility to observe the victim. "Self-blame" was sometimes the tenor in the media about the men in question, why did they not prevented? Well, perhaps because she trusted the woman - apparently a serious mistake, they will have learned their lesson. In addition, it was Benaissa, who knew of their infection, and not the men. Just the looks on die Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe, wenn sie anmahnt, dass mit einem solchen Urteil "die gemeinsame Verantwortung zweier Menschen außer Kraft" gesetzt werde.
[1] Maud Kips: Kriminologisches Journal 1991, S. 125 Strafrecht für Männer, Psychiatrie für Frauen
0 comments:
Post a Comment